FANDOM


Abbreviations: AF: Arlene Francis, BC: Bennett Cerf, DK: Dorothy Kilgallen, FA: Fred Allen, HB: Hal Block, LU: Louis Untermeyer, SA: Steve Allen

1950Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
2/2 Dr. Richard Hoffman, DK, LU, Harold Hoffman Phil Rizutto
2/16 Dr. Richard Hoffman, AF, LU, Harold Hoffman Elliott Roosevelt Arlene Francis' first show
3/2 DK, Dr. Richard Hoffman, AF, LU Artie Shaw
3/16 DK, LU, Wendy Barrie, HB Gypsy Rose Lee Hal Block's first show
4/12 DK, LU, AF, HB Elsa Maxwell
4/26 Sarah Palfrey, LU, AF, HB Abe Burrows
5/10 DK, LU, AF, HB James Farley
5/24 DK, LU, AF, HB Harry James
6/7 DK, LU, AF, HB Dick Haymes
6/21 DK, Garry Moore, AF, HB Dizzy Dean
7/5 Joyce Matthews, LU, AF, HB Tommy Dorsey
7/19 Florence Pritchett, LU, AF, HB Rocky Graziano
8/2 DK, LU, AF, HB William O' Dwyer
8/16 DK, LU, AF, HB Jackie Robinson
8/30 DK, Deems Taylor, AF, HB Faye Emerson
9/13 DK, LU, AF, Joey Adams Bob Cummings
9/27 DK, LU, AF, HB Rise Stevens
10/1 DK, LU, AF, HB Kathleen Winsor
10/8 DK, LU, AF, HB H. V. Kaltenborn
10/15 DK, LU, AF, BC Gloria Swanson Bennett Cerf's first show
10/22 DK, LU, AF, HB Benny Goodman
10/29 LU, Betty Furness, HB Joan Blondell
11/5 LU, Ilka Chase, HB Ed Sullivan
11/12 DK, Jerry Franken, AF, BC Rudy Vallee
11/19 DK, LU, AF, HB John Farbotnik
11/26 DK, LU, AF, HB Cedric Hardwicke
12/3 DK, LU, AF, HB Maxie Rosenbloom
12/10 DK, LU, AF, HB Sarah Churchill
12/17 DK, LU, AF, HB Phil Silvers
12/24 DK, LU, AF, HB Santa Claus
12/31 Betty Furness, LU, AF, Garry Moore Guy Lombardo

1951Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/7 DK, LU, AF, HB Toots Shor
1/14 DK, LU, AF, HB Gladys Swarthout
1/21 DK, LU, AF, HB Boris Karloff
1/28 DK, LU, AF, HB Leo Durocher
2/4 DK, LU, AF, HB Ken Murray
2/11 DK, LU, AF, HB Joan Bennett
2/18 Betty Furness, LU, Margaret Hayes, HB Sugar Ray Robinson
2/25 DK, LU, AF, HB Margaret O' Brian
3/4 Betty Furness, LU, AF, SA Admiral William Halsey Steve Allen's first show
3/11 DK, BC, AF, HB Celeste Holm
3/18 DK, BC, AF, HB Senator Estes Kefauver
3/25 DK, Quentin Reynolds, AF Douglas Fairbanks, Jr.
4/1 DK, BC, AF, HB Jack Dempsey
4/8 DK, Robert Alda, AF, BC Basil Rathbone
4/15 DK, BC, AF, HB Dagmar
4/22 Betty Furness, BC, Mercedes McCambridge, HB Bert Lahr
4/29 Laura Hubson, BC, Constance Moore, HB Hedda Hopper
5/6 DK, Dr. Frank Kingdon, AF, BC Lauritz Melchoir
5/13 DK, BC, AF, HB Veronica Lake
5/20 DK, BC, AF, HB Bob Feller
5/27 DK, BC, AF, HB Richard Rogers
6/3 DK, Red Barber, AF, Ed Sullivan Cab Calloway
6/10 DK, Abe Burrows, AF, BC Eddie Arcaro
6/17 BC, Faye Emerson, HB, AF Michael DeSale
6/24 DK, BC, AF, HB Oscar Levant
7/1 DK, Quincy Howe, AF, HB Helen Hayes
7/8 DK, BC, AF, HB Sherman Billingsley
7/15 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Margaret Whiting
7/22 DK, BC, AF, HB Jerry Colonna
7/29 DK, BC, AF, HB Edward Arnold
8/5 DK, BC, AF, HB Yogi Berra
8/12 DK, BC, AF, HB Ethel Waters
8/19 BC, Coleen Gray, HB, Betty Furness Chico Marx
8/26 BC, Joan Alexander, HB, AF Bernard McFadden
9/2 Jinx Falkenburg, Walter Slezak, DK, SA Buster Keaton
9/9 DK, BC, AF, HB Larraine Day
9/16 DK, BC, AF, HB Fred Waring
9/23 DK, BC, AF, HB Earl Warren
9/30 DK, Peter Donald, AF, SA Harold Stassen
10/7 DK, Rudolph Halley, AF, HB Clayton Moore
10/14 DK, BC, AF, HB Samuel Goldwyn
10/21 DK, BC, AF, HB The Andrews Sisters
10/28 DK, BC, AF, HB James Mason
11/4 DK, BC, AF, HB Melvyn Douglas
11/11 DK, BC, AF, HB Adolphe Menjou
11/18 DK, BC, AF, HB Carmen Miranda
11/25 DK, BC, AF, HB Gabby Hayes
12/2 DK, BC, AF, HB Arthur Murray
12/9 DK, Moss Hart, AF, SA Madeline Carroll
12/16 DK, BC, AF, HB John Payne
12/23 DK, BC, AF, HB Xavier Cugat
12/30 DK, BC, AF, HB George Jessel

1952Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/6 DK, BC, AF, HB Oscar Hammerstein II
1/13 DK, BC, AF, HB Beatrice Lillie
1/20 DK, BC, AF, Robert Q. Lewis Salvador Dali
1/27 DK, Arthur Schwartz, AF, SA Eddie Cantor
2/3 DK, Howard Dietz, AF, SA Sam Levenson
2/10 DK, Leland Hayward, AF, BC David Niven
2/17 DK, BC, AF, HB Mel Tormé
2/24 DK, BC, AF, HB Senator Charles Tobey
3/2 DK, Roland Young, AF, SA Joe Lewis
3/9 DK, BC, AF, HB Ralph Bellamy
3/16 DK, BC, AF, HB Renzo Cesana
3/23 DK, BC, AF, HB Sonja Hennie
3/30 DK, BC, AF, HB Arthur Godfrey
4/6 DK, BC, AF, HB Paul Winchell
4/13 DK, BC, AF, HB Denise Darcel
4/20 DK, BC, AF, HB Hoagy Carmichael
4/27 DK, BC, AF, HB Mickey Rooney
5/4 DK, BC, AF, HB Peter Lorre
5/11 DK, BC, AF, HB Lloyd Nolan
5/18 DK, BC, AF, HB Cecil B. DeMille
5/27 DK, BC, AF, HB Lili Palmer
6/1 DK, BC, AF, HB Yehudi Menuhin
6/8 DK, Richard Kollmar, AF, SA Billy Eckstine
6/15 DK, BC, AF, HB Zasu Pitts
6/22 DK, BC, AF, HB Jack Carson
6/29 DK, BC, AF, HB Sister Elizabeth Kenny
7/6 DK, BC, AF, HB Dane Clark
7/13 DK, BC, AF, HB Conrad Nagel
7/20 DK, BC, AF, HB Ann Sheridan
7/27 DK, BC, AF, HB Victor Borge
8/3 DK, BC, AF, HB Francis the Talking Mule
8/10 DK, BC, AF, HB Frankie Laine
8/17 DK, BC, AF, HB Perle Mesta
8/24 DK, BC, AF, HB Andy Devine
8/31 DK, Artie Shaw, AF, SA Jean Hersholt
9/7 DK, BC, AF, HB Eddie Bracken
9/14 Faye Emerson, BC, AF, HB Neva Jane Langley
9/21 Faye Emerson, BC, AF, HB Elsa Schiaparelli
9/28 DK, BC, AF, Abe Burrows Chuck Dressen
10/5 DK, BC, AF, HB Bette Davis
10/12 DK, BC, AF, HB Ethel Barrymore
10/19 DK, BC, AF, HB Eddie Fisher
10/26 DK, BC, AF, HB Herb Shriner
11/2 DK, BC, AF, HB Barry Fitzgerald
11/9 DK, BC, AF, HB Desi Arnaz
11/16 DK, SA, AF, HB Walter Winchell
11/23 DK, BC, AF, HB Eddie Anderson
11/30 DK, BC, AF, HB Vic Damone
12/7 DK, BC, AF, HB Edward R. Murrow
12/14 DK, BC, AF, HB Cesar Romero
12/21 DK, BC, AF, Robert Q. Lewis Jeanette MacDonald
12/28 DK, BC, AF, Robert Q. Lewis Sally Rand

1953Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/4 DK, BC, AF, SA Rosalind Russell
1/11 DK, BC, AF, SA Joe E. Brown
1/18 DK, BC, AF, SA June Havoc
1/25 DK, SA, AF, HB Margaret Truman
2/1 DK, SA, AF, HB Irene Dunne
2/8 DK, SA, AF, HB Jack Benny
2/15 DK, SA, AF, HB Paul Douglas
2/22 DK, SA, AF, HB The DeMarco Sisters
3/1 DK, SA, AF, HB Jane Froman
3/8 DK, SA, AF, BC Jackie Gleason
3/15 DK, SA, AF, BC Fred MacMurray
3/22 DK, SA, AF, BC Pat O' Brian
3/29 DK, SA, AF, BC Zsa Zsa Gabor
4/5 DK, SA, AF, BC Red Buttons
4/12 DK, SA, AF, BC Anna Magnani
4/19 DK, SA, AF, BC Ida Cantor
4/26 DK, SA, AF, BC Harold Lloyd
5/3 DK, SA, AF, BC Shirley Booth
5/10 DK, SA, AF, BC Marilyn Maxwell
5/17 DK, SA, AF, BC Mickey Mantle
5/24 DK, SA, AF, BC Don Ameche
5/31 Laraine Day, SA, Barbara Kelly, BC Leo Durocher
6/7 DK, SA, Barbara Kelly, BC Nelson Eddy
6/14 DK, SA, AF, BC Senator Margaret Chase Smith
6/21 DK, SA, AF, BC John Sigvard Olsen & Harold Ogden Johnson
6/28 DK, SA, AF, BC Peter Lawford
7/5 DK, SA, AF, BC Judy Holliday
7/12 DK, SA, AF, BC Duke Ellington
7/19 DK, SA, AF, BC Ronald Reagan
7/26 DK, SA, AF, BC General James A. Van Fleet
8/2 DK, SA, AF, BC Charles Coburn
8/9 DK, SA, AF, BC Deborah Kerr
8/16 DK, SA, AF, BC Fred Allen
8/23 DK, SA, AF, BC Billy Rose
8/30 DK, SA, AF, BC Ann Sothern
9/6 DK, SA, AF, Ted Husing Roy Campanella
9/13 DK, SA, AF, BC Ava Gardner
9/20 DK, SA, AF, BC Wally Cox
9/27 DK, SA, AF, BC Lena Horne
10/4 DK, SA, AF, BC Gene Autry
10/11 DK, SA, AF, BC Edward G. Robinson
10/18 DK, SA, AF, BC Eleanor Roosevelt
10/25 DK, SA, AF, BC Greer Garson
11/1 DK, SA, AF, BC Ezio Pinza
11/8 DK, SA, AF, BC Lauren Bacall
11/15 DK, SA, AF, BC Louella Parsons
11/22 DK, SA, AF, BC Van Johnson
11/29 DK, SA, AF, BC George Raft
12/6 DK, SA, AF, BC Nat King Cole
12/13 DK, SA, AF, BC Dave Garroway
12/20 DK, Peter Lind Hayes, AF, BC Kirk Douglas
12/27 DK, Peter Lind Hayes, AF, BC Steve Allen

1954Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/3 DK, SA, AF, BC Mayor Robert F. Wagner, Jr.
1/10 DK, SA, AF, BC Brandon DeWilde
1/17 DK, SA, AF, BC Joan Fontaine
1/24 DK, SA, AF, Cesar Romero 1.Guy Madison, 2.Dean Martin & Jerry Lewis
1/31 DK, SA, AF, Victor Borge Richard Widmark
2/7 DK, SA, AF, David Wayne John Hodiak
2/14 DK, SA, AF, Victor Borge Julius LaRosa
2/21 DK, SA, AF, Deborah Kerr Lucille Ball
2/28 DK, SA, AF, Wally Cox Helen Traubel
3/7 DK, SA, AF, BC Andre Kostelanetz
3/14 DK, SA, AF, BC Louis Armstrong
3/21 Margaret Truman, SA, AF, BC 1. Jill & Dickie Kollmar, 2. Frederic March
3/28 DK, SA, AF, BC Vaughn Monroe
4/4 DK, SA, AF, BC Janet Leigh
4/11 DK, SA, AF, BC William Bendix
4/18 DK, SA, AF, BC Ed Wynn
4/25 DK, SA, AF, BC Arlene Dahl
5/2 DK, SA, AF, BC Jeanne Crain
5/9 DK, SA, Faye Emerson, BC Gertrude Berg
5/16 DK, SA, AF, BC Art Carney
5/23 DK, SA, AF, BC Ted Williams
5/30 DK, SA, AF, BC Eartha Kitt
6/6 Margaret Truman, SA, AF, BC George Burns & Gracie Allen
6/13 Margaret Truman, SA, AF, BC Les Paul & Mary Ford
6/20 SA, Audrey Meadows, BC Doris Day
6/27 DK, SA, Phyllis Cerf, BC Senator Karl E. Mundt
7/4 DK, SA, AF, BC Spike Jones
7/11 DK, Jack Paar, AF, BC Willie Mays
7/18 DK, SA, AF, BC Judy Canova
7/25 DK, SA, AF, BC Dorothy McGuire
8/1 DK, SA, AF, BC Jayne Meadows
8/8 DK, SA, AF, BC Eva Gabor
8/15 DK, FA, AF, BC Buffalo Bob Smith & Howdy Doody Fred Allen's first show
8/22 DK, SA, AF, BC Johnnie Ray
8/29 DK, SA, AF, BC 1.Ivy Baker Priest, 2.Debbie Reynolds
9/5 DK, Jack Carter, AF, BC Sal Maglie & Duke Snider
9/12 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC 1.Lee Meriwether, 2.Alfred Hitchcock
9/19 DK, SA, AF, BC** 1.Robert Young, 2.Gina Lollobrigada Originally broadcast in color, from CBS Studio 72
9/26 DK, FA, AF, BC 1.Roy Rogers & Dale Evans, 2.Red Skelton
10/3 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Jeff Chandler
10/10 DK, FA, AF, BC Fernando Lamas
10/17 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Merle Oberon
10/24 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
10/31 DK, FA, AF, BC Ray Milliand
11/7 Fran Allison, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Dick Powell
11/14 DK, FA, AF, BC Elizabeth Taylor
11/21 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Ginger Rogers
11/28 DK, FA, AF, BC Herbert Marshall
12/5 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Louis Jordan
12/12 DK, FA, AF, BC 1.Clarence Nash, 2.Bob Hope
12/19 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Dan Dailey
12/26 DK, FA, AF, BC Edgar Bergen & Charlie McCarthy

1955Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/2 DK, Sam Levenson, Betty Furness, BC Eve Arden
1/9 DK, FA, Janet Leigh, BC Tony Curtis
1/16 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Esther Williams
1/23 DK, FA, AF, BC Dennis Day
1/30 DK, FA, AF, BC Shelley Winters
2/6 DK, FA, AF, Sam Levenson Pearl Bailey Fifth anniversary show
2/13 DK, FA, AF, Louis Jourdan Senator John McClellan
2/20 DK, FA, AF, Ezio Pinza Dorothy Lamour
2/27 DK, FA, AF, Reginald Gardiner Portland Hoffa
3/6 DK, FA, AF, BC Lily Pons
3/13 DK, FA, AF, BC Sammy Davis, Jr.
3/20 DK, FA, AF, BC Terry Moore
3/27 DK, Wally Cox, AF, BC Tyrone Power
4/3 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Fred Astaire
4/10 DK, FA, AF, BC 1.Amelia Adler, 2.Rhonda Fleming
4/17 DK, FA, AF, BC Barbara Ann Scott Rules Change episode. Panelists no longer give free guesses, and during the Mystery Guest round, they give one question at a time.
4/24 DK, FA, AF, BC Rosemary Clooney
5/1 DK, FA, Larraine Day, BC Gracie Fields
5/8 DK, FA, Larraine Day, BC Hildegarde
5/15 AF, FA, Mary Healy, BC Marge & Gower Champion
5/22 AF, FA, Mary Healy, BC Van Johnson
5/29 DK, FA, AF, BC The McGuire Sisters
6/5 DK, FA, AF, BC Conrad Hilton
6/12 DK, FA, AF, BC Tom Ewell
6/19 DK, FA, Betty White, BC Arnold Stang
6/26 DK, FA, Betty White, BC Jose Ferrer
7/3 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Audie Murphy
7/10 DK, Jack Paar, AF, BC Sheree North
7/17 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Fred Allen
7/24 DK, FA, AF, BC Robert Q. Lewis
7/31 DK, FA, AF, BC Ty Cobb
8/7 DK, FA, AF, BC Burl Ives
8/14 DK, FA, AF, BC Paul Muni
8/21 DK, FA, AF, BC 1.William Parker, 2.Audrey Meadows
8/28 DK, FA, AF, BC 1. Lily Dache, 2. Peggy King
9/4 DK, FA, AF, BC Jean Pierre Aumont
9/11 DK, FA, AF, BC Joe E. Lewis
9/18 DK, FA, AF, BC Joe DiMaggio
9/25 DK, FA, AF, BC 1. Douglas Fairbanks, Jr, 2. Jackie Gleason
10/2 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Lucille Ball & Desi Arnaz
10/9 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, Gail Storm, BC Hal March
10/16 DK, FA, AF, BC Tommy & Jimmy Dorsey
10/23 DK, FA, AF, BC 1.Herman Wouk, 2.Van Heflin
10/30 DK, FA, AF, BC 1.Florence Chadwick, 2.Jean Simmons
11/6 DK, FA, AF, BC Harry Belafonte
11/13 DK, FA, AF, BC Phil Silvers Panelists now enter the stage and walk to their seats at the beginning of the program.
11/20 BC, AF, FA, DK 1.Richard Kollmar, 2.Garry Moore
11/27 AF, BC, DK, FA Jack Palance
12/4 DK, FA, AF, BC 1.George Axelrod, 2.Vivian Blaine
12/11 DK, FA, AF, BC Martha Raye
12/18 DK, FA, AF, BC Margaret Sullavan
12/25 DK, FA, AF, BC Peter Lind Hayes & Mary Healy

1956Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/1 DK, FA, Vivian Blaine, BC 1. Mark Goodson & Bill Todman, 2. Jackie Cooper
1/8 DK, FA, Vivian Blaine, BC Gary Crosby
1/15 DK, FA, AF, BC Edward G. Robinson
1/22 DK, FA, AF, BC Henry Cabot Lodge, Jr.
1/29 Herman Wouk, DK, FA, SA Victor Borge
2/5 AF, Desi Arnaz, DK, FA 1. Randolph Churchill, 2. Kim Novak
2/12 AF, FA, DK, BC 1. Jules Montenier, 2. Jayne Mansfield
2/19 AF, FA, DK, BC 1. Gen. Mark Clark, 2. Rodgers & Hammerstein
2/26 AF, FA, DK, BC 1. Bill Talbert, 2. Robert Taylor
3/4 AF, FA, DK, BC Betty Hutton
3/11 AF, FA, DK, BC 1. Emmett Kelly, 2. Dinah Shore Fred Allen died of a heart attack the Saturday after this episode was filmed in either Kinescope or Regular Film in B&W.
3/18 AF, SA, DK, BC Cyd Charisse
3/25 AF, Garry Moore, DK, BC 1. Ford Frick, 2. Linda Darnell
4/1 AF, Victor Borge, DK, BC 1. Bill Cullen, Jayne Meadows, Henry Morgan & Faye Emerson, 2. Imogene Coca
4/8 AF, Johnny Carson, DK, BC Ray Bolger
4/15 BC, Celeste Holm, Robert Q. Lewis, Elsa Maxwell 1. Micol Fontana, 2. Eddie Fisher & Debbie Reynolds
4/22 AF, Peter Lind Hayes, DK, BC Hedda Hopper
4/29 AF, Paul Winchell, DK, BC 1. Marguerite Higgins, 2. Edgar Bergen & Mortimer Snerd
5/6 AF, Peter Lind Hayes, DK, BC 1. Justice William O. Douglas, 2. Mary Healy
5/13 AF, Peter Lind Hayes, DK, Eammon Andrews Peter Lawford
5/20 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, Hedda Hopper, Ronald Reagan Art Linkletter
5/27 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, Hedda Hopper, Eammon Andrews Ozzie & Harriet Nelson
6/3 AF, Paul Winchell, DK, Peter Lawford 1. Frank Lloyd Wright, 2. Liberace
6/10 DK, Jack E. Leonard, AF, George Axelrod 1. Charles Atlas, 2. Jane Powell
6/17 AF, Paul Winchell, DK, Robert Q. Lewis 1. Arthur Murray, 2. Pier Angeli & Vic Damone
6/24 DK, Paul Winchell, AF, BC 1. The Cincinatti Reds, 2. Bob & Linda Hope
7/1 AF, Jack E. Leonard, DK, BC Sugar Ray Robinson
7/8 DK, Jack E. Leonard, AF, BC Margaret Truman
7/15 AF, Jack E. Leonard, Margaret Truman, BC 1. Clifton Daniel, 2. Ted Lewis
7/22 AF, Paul Winchell, Vivian Blaine, BC Jerry Lewis
7/29 DK, Roger Price, AF, BC James Mason
8/5 AF, Paul Winchell, DK, BC 1. Mayor Richard J. Daley, 2. Carol Morris
8/12 DK, Dr. Bergen Evans, AF, BC 1. The CBS News Convention Team, 2. Perle Mesta Episode filmed in Chicago, Illinois via WBBM-TV CBS 2.
8/19 AF, Robert Q. Lewis, DK, BC Sylvana Mangano
8/26 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC 1. Dan Topping, 2. Walter Pidgeon
9/2 AF, Walter Pidgeon, DK, BC Marisa Pavan
9/9 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Edie Adams & Ernie Kovacs
9/16 AF, Phil Rizzuto, DK, BC 1. Jacques Cousteau, 2. William Bendix
9/23 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC 1. June Taylor, 2. William Holden
9/30 AF, James Mason, DK, BC 1. George Stevens, 2. Claudette Colbert
10/7 DK, Phil Rizutto, AF, BC 1. Sal Maglie, 2. Ann Miller
10/14 AF, David Niven, DK, BC Jo Stafford
10/21 DK, David Niven, AF, BC 1. Alan Jay Lerner & Frederick Loewe, 2. Bishop Fulton J. Sheen
10/28 AF, Douglas Fairbanks Jr, DK, BC Charlton Heston
11/4 DK, John Cameron Swayze, AF, BC 1. Beatrice Lillie, 2. Jack O' Brien
11/11 AF, Jerry Lewis, DK, BC Walt Disney
11/18 DK, William Bendix, AF, BC 1. James Kilgallen, 2. Nanette Fabray
11/25 AF, Burgess Meredith, DK, BC Charles Laughton
12/2 DK, Stubby Kaye, AF, BC Milton Berle
12/9 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC*** Shelley Winters Martin Gabel's first show
12/16 DK, Walter Pidgeon, AF, BC 1. Floyd Patterson, 2. Vincent Price
12/23 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Steve Allen & Jayne Meadows
12/30 DK, Stubby Kaye, AF, BC 1. The Harlem Globetrotters, 2. Bert Lahr

1957Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/6 AF, Peter Lind Hayes, DK, BC Yul Brynner
1/13 DK, Peter Lawford, AF, BC Robert Montgomery
1/20 AF, Stubby Kaye, DK, BC George Gobel
1/27 DK, Peter Lawford, AF, BC 1. Salvador Dali, 2. Lillian Roth
2/3 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, Richard Kollmar Tab Hunter
2/10 DK, Tab Hunter, AF, BC 1. Gen. Alfred Greunther, 2. Fred MacMurray & June Haver
2/17 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC 1. Mike Todd, 2. Ginger Rogers
2/24 DK, BC, Jeannie Carson, AF Robert Wagner
3/3 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Robert Mitchum
3/10 DK, James Michener, AF, BC 1. James C. Hagerty, 2. Charles Boyer
3/17 AF, Robert Preston, DK, BC 1. Dr. Norman Vincent Peale, 2. Judy Holliday
3/24 DK, Melvyn Douglas, AF, BC Mamie Van Doren
3/31 AF, Robert Q. Lewis, DK, BC Hedy Lamarr
4/7 DK, Walter Pidgeon, AF, BC Fernando Lamas
4/14 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Helen Hayes
4/21 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Robert Young
4/28 AF, Senator George A. Smathers, DK, BC 1. Jim Piersall, 2. Paul Douglas Challengers greet the panel after the game for the first time.
5/5 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Mickey Rooney
5/12 DK, Adolphe Menjou, Greer Garson, BC 1. The Ziegfeld Girls, 2. Walter Brennan
5/19 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Ann Sothern
5/26 AF, Errol Flynn, DK, BC Sammy Davis, Jr.
6/2 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Eddie & Marilyn Cantor
6/9 DK, Ozzie Nelson, Janet Blair, BC Johnnie Ray
6/16 AF, Clifton Daniel, DK, BC Peggy Lee
6/23 DK, James C. Hagerty, AF, Martin Gabel Gene Kelly
6/30 AF, Ernie Kovacs, DK, Martin Gabel Sal Mineo
7/7 DK, Eamonn Andrews, AF, Martin Gabel Buddy Hackett
7/14 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC- NEW INTRO Anthony Franciosa & Shelley Winters
7/21 DK, Stubby Kaye, AF, BC Julius LaRosa
7/28 AF, Phil Rizutto, DK, BC Anne Jeffreys & Robert Sterling
8/4 DK, Don Ameche, AF, BC Jayne Mansfield
8/11 AF, Ernie Kovacs, DK, BC 1. Edie Adams, 2. Jane Russell
8/18 DK, Ernie Kovacs, AF, BC Zsa Zsa Gabor
8/25 AF, Ernie Kovacs, DK, BC Miss Gene Tierney
9/1 DK, Ernie Kovacs, AF, BC Buster Keaton
9/8 AF, Robert Young, DK, BC 1. Ernie Kovacs, 2. Doris Day
9/15 DK, Jim Backus, AF, BC 1.Erle Stanley Gardner, 2.George Sanders
9/22 AF, Jim Backus, DK, BC Patti Page
9/29 DK, Ernie Kovacs, AF, Cesar Romero 1. Henry J. Kaiser, 2. Julie London Bennett Cerf subbed for John Daly as host for this episode.
10/6 AF, Ernie Kovacs, DK, BC Danny Thomas
10/13 Ernie Kovacs, AF, Mike Todd, BC 1. Elsa Maxwell, 2. Pat O' Brien
10/20 DK, Jim Backus, AF, BC Irene Dunne
10/27 AF, Ernie Kovacs, DK, BC Spring Byington
11/3 DK, Ernie Kovacs, AF, BC Jack Lemmon
11/10 AF, Robert Monkhouse, DK, BC Gale Storm
11/17 DK, Jim Backus, AF, BC Eva Gabor
11/24 AF, Peter Ustinov, DK, BC Margaret O' Brien
12/1 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Errol Flynn
12/8 AF, Peter Ustinov, DK, BC 1. Edith Young & Phyllis Cerf, 2. Joan Crawford
12/15 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Sophie Tucker
12/22 AF, Robert Preston, DK, BC Cyril Ritchard
12/29 DK, Lloyd Nolan, AF, BC 1. Jolie Gabor, 2. Tony Perkins

1958Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/5 DK, Martin Gabel, Hedy Lamarr, BC Pat Boone
1/12 Larraine Day, Mickey Rooney, Esther Williams, Jack Lemmon 1. Duke Snider, 2. Bob Cummings Episode filmed in Los Angeles, California. Roy Rowan is The Sub-Announcer.
1/19 AF, Ricardo Montalban, DK, BC Ralph Bellamy
1/26 DK, Edward Mulhare, AF, BC Xavier Cugat & Abbe Lane
2/2 AF, Jonathan Winters, DK, BC 1. Congressman James Roosevelt, 2. Patrice Munsel
2/9 DK, Cesar Romero, AF, BC Phil Silvers
2/16 AF, Keenan Wynn, DK, Martin Gabel Milton Berle
2/23 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Judy Holliday
3/2 AF, Ralph Bellamy, DK, BC Lena Horne
3/9 DK, Vincent Price, AF, BC Jack Paar
3/16 AF, Congressman James Roosevelt, DK, BC Peter Lind Hayes & Mary Healy
3/23 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Anita Ekberg
3/30 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Don Murray & Hope Lange
4/6 DK, Orson Welles, AF, BC Greer Garson
4/13 AF, Cesar Romero, DK, BC Bob Hope Clifton Fadiman is the host.
4/20 AF, Martin Gabel, Dana Wynter, BC Jane Powell Clifton Fadiman is the host.
4/27 AF, Martin Gabel, Dana Wynter, BC Gracie Fields
5/4 DK, Gig Young, AF, BC Tennessee Ernie Ford
5/11 AF, Robert Ryan, DK, BC Miyoshi Umeki
5/18 DK, Ralph Bellamy, AF, BC Steve Allen
5/25 AF, Eamonn Andrews, DK, BC Olivia de Havilland
6/1 DK, Eamonn Andrews, AF, BC Betty Hutton
6/8 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Fred Astaire
6/15 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Bob Crosby
6/22 AF, Jack Lemmon, DK, BC Andy Griffith
6/29 DK, Dick Clark, AF, BC Sophia Loren
7/6 AF, Dana Andrews, DK, BC Benny Goodman
7/13 DK, Bob Crosby, AF, Martin Gabel Dorothy Lamour
7/20 AF, Tom Poston, DK, BC Kathryn Grayson
7/27 DK, Dick Clark, AF, BC Esther Williams
8/3 AF, Tom Poston, DK, BC Van Cliburn
8/10 DK, George Sanders, AF, BC Althea Gibson
8/17 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Steve Lawrence & Eydie Gormé
8/24 DK, Rudy Vallee, AF, BC Dick Powell
8/31 AF, Tom Poston, DK, BC Polly Bergen
9/7 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Eva Marie Saint
9/14 AF, John Payne, DK, BC Ed Sullivan
9/21 DK, David Niven, AF, BC Robert Young & Jane Wyatt
9/28 AF, David Niven, DK, BC Roy Rogers
10/5 DK, Sir Cedric Hardwicke, AF, BC Darryl F. Zanuck
10/12 AF, Dana Andrews, Faye Emerson, BC Joe E. Lewis
10/19 AF, Martin Gabel, Faye Emerson, BC Gordon MacRae
10/26 AF, Tom Poston, DK, BC Imogene Coca
11/2 DK, Gordon MacRae, AF, BC Robert Wagner
11/9 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Charles Boyer
11/16 DK, Peter Lind Hayes, AF, BC 1. Governor Edmund Brown, 2. Harry Belafonte
11/23 AF, Victor Borge, DK, BC Anna Maria Alberghetti
11/30 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
12/7 DK, Pat Boone, AF, BC Jose Ferrer
12/14 AF, Tom Poston, DK, BC Kathryn Crosby
12/21 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Jayne Meadows
12/28 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS

1959Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/4 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Celeste Holm
1/11 AF, Dick Powell, DK, BC Joseph Cotten
1/18 DK, Van Heflin, AF, BC Richard Boone
1/25 AF, David Niven, DK, BC Paul Newman
2/1 DK, James Roosevelt, AF, Martin Gabel 1. Ingemar Johansson, 2. Burl Ives
2/8 AF, Tom Poston, DK, Martin Gabel Marge & Gower Champion
2/15 DK, Bob Cummings, AF, Martin Gabel Maria Schell
2/22 AF, Richard Boone, DK, Martin Gabel Johnny Mathis
3/1 DK, Keenan Wynn, AF, BC Noel Coward
3/8 AF, Jack Lemmon, DK, BC Fred MacMurray
3/15 DK, David Susskind, AF, BC Sammy Davis, Jr.
3/22 AF, Mel Ferrer, DK, BC Lana Turner
3/29 DK, Dore Schary, AF, BC Cornelia Otis Skinner
4/5 AF, Richard Boone, DK, BC Jeanne Crain
4/12 DK, Vincent Price, AF, BC Frankie Laine
4/19 AF, Van Cliburn, DK, BC Hermione Gingold
4/26 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
5/3 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Andy Griffith
5/10 AF, Eamonn Andrews, DK, BC Milton Berle An unknown man ran on stage for a moment during the Mystery Guest segment.
5/17 DK, Eamonn Andrews, AF, BC 1. Franklin Heller, 2. Pat Suzuki
5/24 AF, Eamonn Andrews, DK, BC Debbie Reynolds
5/31 DK, Gig Young, AF, BC Gypsy Rose Lee
6/7 AF, Cesar Romero, DK, BC The McGuire Sisters
6/14 AF, Martin Gabel, Zsa Zsa Gabor, BC Anthony Perkins
6/21 AF, SA, Jayne Meadows, BC Jack Benny
6/28 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC 1. Ruby Goldstein, 2. Red Buttons Eamonn Andrews is the guest host on this program.
7/5 AF, Garson Kanin, DK, BC William Bendix
7/12 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Eartha Kitt
7/19 AF, Robert Q. Lewis, DK, BC The Andrews Sisters
7/26 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Cliff Arquette First broadcast to be recorded at an earlier time
8/2 AF, Ben Gazzara, DK, BC Eddie Hodges
8/9 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Julie London
8/16 AF, Robert Q. Lewis, DK, BC 1. Archie Moore, 2. Suzy Parker
8/23 DK, Mort Sahl, AF, BC Tony Randall
8/30 AF, Max Shulman, DK, BC Rick Nelson
9/6 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Esther Williams
9/13 AF, Chuck Connors, DK, BC 1. Branch Rickey, 2. June Allyson
9/20 AF, Groucho Marx, DK, BC Claudette Colbert
9/27 DK, Ben Gazzara, AF, BC Garry Moore
10/4 AF, Mort Sahl, DK, BC George Montgomery & Dinah Shore
10/11 DK, John Payne, AF, BC Hedda Hopper
10/18 AF, Anthony Perkins, DK, BC Gary Cooper
10/25 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Phil Silvers
11/1 AF, Ray Milland, DK, BC Harry Belafonte
11/8 DK, Art Linkletter, AF, BC Paul Newman & Joanne Woodward
11/15 AF, Shelley Berman, DK, BC Fabian
11/22 DK, James Michener, AF, BC Walter Brennan
11/29 DK, Martin Gabel, Paulette Goddard, BC Richard Rodgers & Oscar Hammerstein II
12/6 DK, Martin Gabel, Joan Collins, BC Art Carney
12/13 AF, David Niven, DK, BC Arlene Dahl
12/20 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
12/27 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Maureen O' Hara

1960Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/3 AF, David Niven, DK, BC Tom Poston
1/10 DK, Dana Andrews, Eunice Gayson, BC George Jessel
1/17 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
1/24 AF, William Bendix, DK, BC Jack Paar
1/31 DK, Stanley Kramer, AF, BC Nelson Eddy
2/7 AF, Martyn Green, DK, Martin Gabel Julie Andrews 500th episode
2/14 DK, SA, AF, Martin Gabel Peter Lorre
2/21 AF, SA, DK, Martin Gabel Charles Laughton
2/28 DK, Ben Gazzara, AF, Martin Gabel Peggy Lee
3/6 AF, Laurence Harvey, Betsy Palmer, BC Gisele MacKenzie
3/13 AF, Richard Boone, Betty White, BC Arthur & Kathryn Murray
3/20 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
3/27 DK, Mort Sahl, AF, BC Shelley Winters
4/3 DK, Martin Gabel, Polly Bergen, BC Jane Fonda
4/10 DK, Jerome Hines, AF, BC Jack Lemmon
4/17 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Jonathan Winters Rules Change episode. At the start of each regular game, John Daly tells the panel whether the contestant deals in a product or services.
4/24 DK, Adolph Green, AF, BC Bob Cummings
5/1 AF, Jean-Pierre Aumont, DK, BC Laurence Harvey
5/8 DK, Dick Van Dyke, AF, BC Gertrude Berg
5/15 AF, Gore Vidal, DK, BC James Cagney
5/22 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC June Allyson
5/29 AF, Anthony Perkins, DK, BC Jane Wyman
6/5 DK, Mel Torme, AF, BC Bobby Darin
6/12 AF, Joey Bishop, DK, BC Van Johnson First episode broadcast from CBS Studio 52.
6/19 DK, Eamonn Andrews, AF, BC Ingemar Johansson
6/26 AF, Eamonn Andrews, DK, BC Elaine May & Mike Nichols
7/3 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Trapp family choir
7/10 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Shelley Berman
7/17 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, BC Jerry Lewis
7/24 AF, Alan King, DK, BC Zsa Zsa Gabor
7/31 DK, Dirk Bogarde, AF, BC Myrna Loy
8/7 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC 1. Arnold Palmer, 2. Dina Merrill
8/14 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Jesse Owens
8/21 AF, Alan King, DK, BC Buddy Hackett
8/28 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, BC Bette Davis
9/4 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC Ralph Bellamy
9/11 DK, Nick Adams, AF, BC 1. Carl Sandburg, 2. Milton Berle
9/18 AF, Joey Bishop, DK, BC Cantinflas
9/25 DK, Chuck Connors, AF, BC Red Skelton
10/2 AF, SA, DK, BC 1. Kirk Douglas, 2. Mickey Rooney
10/9 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, BC 1. Billy Graham, 2. Anthony Quinn
10/16 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC Danny Kaye
10/23 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC 1. Ralph Houk, 2. Janet Leigh
10/30 AF, Joey Bishop, DK, BC Frankie Laine
11/6 DK, Jack Lemmon, AF, BC Joey Bishop
11/13 AF, Joey Bishop, DK, BC John Wayne
11/20 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
11/27 DK, Alan King, AF, BC Maurice Evans
12/4 AF, Lord Robert Boothby, DK, BC Nancy Kwan
12/11 DK, Otto Preminger, AF, BC Stephen Boyd
12/18 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Edward G. Robinson
12/25 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Richerd Kollmar, Florence Randall, Martin Gabel, & Phyllis Cerf

1961Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/1 AF, Shelley Berman, Faye Emerson, BC Lucille Ball Ralph Paul replaces Hal Simms as announcer
1/8 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, BC 1. Wilt Chamberlain, 2. Joan Crawford
1/15 AF, Gig Young, DK, BC Henry Fonda
1/22 AF, Governor William Quinn, Betsy Palmer, BC Mahalia Jackson
1/29 AF, Shelley Berman, Rita Gam, BC 1. Oleg Cassini, 2. Julie Newmar
2/5 Martin Gabel, Debbie Reynolds, Anthony Perkins, AF Dorothy Kilgallen Johnny Olsen replaces Ralph Paul as announcer
2/12 AF, Art Linkletter, DK, Martin Gabel Tallulah Bankhead
2/19 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, Martin Gabel Barrie Chase
2/26 AF, Joey Bishop, DK, BC Bobby Darin
3/5 DK, Art Linkletter, Betty White, BC Genevieve
3/12 AF, Joey Bishop, DK, BC Al, Jimmy, & Harry Ritz
3/19 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, BC Nat King Cole
3/26 AF, Joey Bishop, DK, BC Gary Crosby
4/2 DK, Shelley Berman, AF, BC June Allyson
4/9 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Gordon & Sheila MacRae
4/16 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC 1. Raoul Levy, 2. Julie London
4/23 AF, Hugh Hefner, DK, BC Peter Ustinov
4/30 DK, Johnny Carson, AF, BC Anna Maria Alberghetti
5/7 AF, Cyril Ritchard, DK, BC Carol Burnett
5/14 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, BC Phil, Dennis, & Lindsay Crosby
5/21 AF, Abe Burrows, DK, BC Tony Martin
5/28 DK, Johnny Carson, AF, BC Sophia Loren
6/4 AF, Joey Bishop, DK, BC 1. John Sellers, 2. Phil Silvers
6/11 DK, Harry Belafonte, AF, BC Mort Sahl
6/18 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC George Burns
6/25 DK, Suzy Parker, BC Alan King
7/2 DK, Martin Gabel, Suzy Parker, BC Yogi Berra
7/9 DK, SA, Jayne Meadows, BC Bill Cullen
7/16 AF, Abe Burrows, DK, BC The McGuire Sisters
7/23 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, BC Eartha Kitt
7/30 AF, Johnny Carson, DK, BC Nancy Walker
8/6 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
8/13 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC Peter Lind Hayes & Mary Healy
8/20 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, BC 1. Jacques Picard, 2. Mitch Miller
8/27 AF, Jerry Lewis, DK, BC Connie Francis
9/3 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Ben Gazzara
9/10 AF, Alan King, DK, BC Maria Fletcher
9/17 DK, Art Linkletter, AF, BC Dick Powell
9/24 AF, Garry Moore, DK, BC Victor Borge
10/1 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Gertrude Berg
10/8 AF, Hugh O' Brian, DK, BC Joe E. Lewis
10/15 DK, Art Linkletter, AF, BC Piper Laurie
10/22 AF, Barry Nelson, DK, BC Yves Montand
10/29 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
11/5 DK, Danny Kaye, AF, BC Louella Parsons
11/12 AF, Ray Bolger, DK, BC Simone Signoret
11/19 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Bob Hope Jack Clark announcer
11/26 AF, Darren McGavin, DK, BC Rudy Vallee
12/3 DK, John Payne, AF, BC Janet Leigh
12/10 AF, Johnny Carson, DK, BC 1. Charles H. Goren, 2. Michael Redgrave
12/17 DK, Abe Burrows, DK, BC Carol Burnett
12/24 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Hugh O' Brian
12/31 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Mickey Rooney

1962Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/7 DK, Richard Boone, AF, BC Sammy Davis, Jr.
1/14 BC, Dana Andrews, DK, Johnny Carson Tuesday Weld
1/21 DK, Tony Randall, Jane Powell, BC 1. Gene Fullmer, 2. Ella Fitzgerald
1/28 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Polly Bergen
2/4 AF, Buddy Hackett, DK, BC 1. Mark Goodson & Bill Todman, 2. Bob Newhart
2/11 DK, Tony Randall, AF, Martin Gabel 1. Toots Shor, 2. Johnny Carson
2/18 AF, Buddy Hackett, DK, Martin Gabel Horst Bucholtz
2/25 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
3/4 AF, Robert Morse, DK, BC Olivia de Havilland
3/11 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC 1. Sargent Shriver, 2. Van Cliburn
3/18 AF, Alan King, DK, BC Keely Smith
3/25 DK, George Gobel, AF, BC Eddie Fisher
4/1 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC 1. Chubby Checker, 2. Joan Collins
4/8 DK, Merv Griffin, AF, BC-NEW INTRO The McGuire Sisters
4/15 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC Casey Stengel
4/22 DK, Dennis Weaver, AF, BC Hedda Hopper
4/29 AF, Maurice Edelman, DK, BC Bob Cummings
5/6 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, BC Abe Burrows
5/13 AF, Joey Bishop, DK, BC Buddy Hackett
5/20 DK, Merv Griffin, AF, BC 1. Sir Edmund Hillary, 2. Diahann Carroll
5/27 AF, Johnny Carson, DK, BC Shirley Booth
6/3 DK, Buddy Hackett, AF, BC Raymond Burr
6/10 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Rosemary Clooney
6/17 AF, Merv Griffin, Faye Emerson, BC James Mason
6/24 AF, Dave Garroway, DK, BC Jerry Lewis
7/1 DK, Allen Ludden, AF, BC Anne Bancroft
7/8 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Walter Pidgeon
7/15 DK, Tom Poston, AF, BC 1. Willie Mays, 2. Paul Anka
7/22 AF, Buddy Hackett, DK, BC 1. Norma Nolan, 2. Benny Goodman
7/29 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, BC Richard Chamberlain & Raymond Massey
8/5 AF, Alan King, DK, BC Ginger Rogers
8/12 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Red Buttons
8/19 DK, Abe Burrows, AF, BC Shirley Jones
8/26 AF, Allen Ludden, Betty Furness, BC Carol Channing
9/2 AF, Liberace, DK, BC Jack E. Leonard
9/9 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Dick Powell
9/16 AF, Art Linkletter, DK, BC 1. Daryl F. Zanuck, 2. Jacqueline Mayer
9/23 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
9/30 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC 1. William Schuman, 2. Gordon & Sheila MacRae
10/7 AF, Victor Borge, DK, BC Melina Mercouri Famous episode where a man walks on stage during the Mystery Guest segment.
10/14 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Joan Crawford
10/21 AF, Harry Belafonte, DK, BC Robert Ryan & Nanette Fabray
10/28 DK, Peter Ustinov, AF, BC Tony Martin
11/4 AF, Buddy Hackett, DK, BC 1. Dudley Moore, Peter Cook, Jonathan Miller, & Allen Bennett, 2. Robert Goulet
11/11 DK, Art Linkletter, AF, BC Bette Davis
11/18 AF, SA, DK, BC 1. Joseph L. Mankiewicz, 2. Jane Russell
11/25 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Charles Boyer
12/2 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC 1. James Edward Day, 2. Steve Lawrence & Eydie Gorme
12/9 DK, Alan King, AF, BC Bobby Darin
12/16 AF, Steve Lawrence, DK, BC Edward G. Robinson
12/23 DK, Buddy Hackett, AF, BC Liberace
12/30 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Vaughn Meader

1963Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/6 DK, Peter Ustinov, AF, BC Bert Lahr
1/13 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, Jane Fonda, BC Lee Remick
1/20 AF, Peter Cook, DK, BC Montgomery Clift
1/27 DK, Steve Lawrence, AF, Martin Gabel Maurice Chevalier
2/3 AF, Peter Cook, Phyllis Newman, Martin Gabel Anthony Quinn
2/10 DK, Shelley Berman, AF, BC Phyllis Diller
2/17 Phyllis Newman, Peter Ustinov, AF, BC Anthony Perkins
2/24 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
3/3 DK, Allen Ludden, AF, BC Robert Preston
3/10 AF, Steve Lawrence, DK, BC 1. Hedda Hopper, 2. Shirley Booth
3/17 DK, Edward Mulhare, AF, BC Ed Sullivan
3/24 AF, Johnny Carson, Phyllis Newman, BC Danny Kaye
3/31 BC, Kitty Carlisle, Tony Randall, Phyllis Newman Arthur Godfrey
4/7 Phyllis Newman, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Anne Bancroft
4/14 AF, Dick Boone, Phyllis Newman, BC Jimmy Durante
4/21 Phyllis Newman, Peter Cook, AF, BC 1.Louis Nizer, 2.Carol Channing
4/28 AF, Shelley Berman, DK, BC Judy Holliday
5/5 AF, Buddy Hackett, DK, BC Lucille Ball & Bob Hope
5/12 DK, Joey Bishop, AF, BC Peter Lawford
5/19 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Sid Caesar
5/26 DK, Eamonn Andrews, Kitty Carlisle, BC 1. Gil Hodges, 2. Peter Ustinov
6/2 DK, Tony Randall, Dina Merrill, BC 1. Eamonn Andrews, 2. Jean Pierre Aumont
6/9 DK, Maurice Edelman, Phyllis Newman, BC Andy Williams
6/16 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Geraldine Page
6/23 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Allen Ludden & Betty White
6/30 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Van Johnson
7/7 AF, Woody Allen, DK, BC Peter, Paul, & Mary
7/14 DK, Peter Cook, AF, BC Paul Ford
7/21 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Edie Adams
7/28 AF, Peter Cook, Phyllis Newman, BC Ralph Richardson
8/4 AF, Merv Griffin, DK, BC Peggy Cass
8/11 AF, Tony Randall, Phyllis Newman, BC The Kingston Trio
8/18 AF, Martin Gabel, Phyllis Newman, BC Richard Boone
8/25 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Joey Bishop
9/1 DK, Milt Kamen, AF, BC Mitch Miller
9/8 AF, Tom Poston, DK, BC Hermione Gingold
9/15 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Allen Funt
9/22 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Gordon & Sheila MacRae
9/29 DK, Steve Lawrence, AF, BC Eydie Gorme
10/6 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
10/13 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Groucho Marx
10/20 AF, Art Linkletter, DK, BC Carol Lawrence
10/27 DK, Allen Ludden, AF, BC Ethel Merman
11/3 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
11/10 DK, Joseph Mankiewicz, AF, BC James Stewart
11/17 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC 1. Y. A. Tittle, 2. Charles Boyer
11/24 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
12/1 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Alan King
12/8 DK, Peter Cook, AF, BC Sophie Tucker
12/15 AF, Steve Lawrence, DK, BC Victor Borge
12/22 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Mark Goodson & Bill Todman
12/29 AF, Robert Q. Lewis, DK, BC Ginger Rogers

1964Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/5 DK, Woody Allen, AF, BC Pearl Bailey
1/12 AF, Robert Preston, DK, BC Noel Coward
1/19 DK, SA, AF, BC Van Heflin
1/26 AF, Arthur Godfrey, DK, BC Jonathan Winters
2/2 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC George Burns
2/9 AF, Bobby Darin, DK, BC 1. Johnny Mercer, 2. Jane Fonda
2/16 DK, Buddy Hackett, AF, BC Carol Burnett
2/23 AF, Congressman John Lindsay, DK, BC Bert Lahr
3/1 DK, Woody Allen, AF, Martin Gabel Debbie Reynolds
3/8 AF, Steve Lawrence, DK, Martin Gabel 1. Stan Musial, 2. Steve Allen
3/15 DK, Steve Lawrence, AF, Robert Q. Lewis Allan Sherman
3/22 AF, Ross Hunter, DK, BC Louis Armstrong
3/29 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Bette Davis
4/5 AF, Allen Ludden, DK, BC 1. Lowell Thomas, 2. Van Cliburn
4/12 DK, Gore Vidal, AF, BC Barbra Streisand
4/19 AF, Buddy Hackett, DK, BC Edie Adams
4/26 DK, Steve Lawrence, AF, BC 1. Yogi Berra, 2. Louis Jourdan
5/3 AF, Charles Nelson Reilly, DK, BC The McGuire Sisters
5/10 DK, Allan Sherman, AF, BC 1. Bill Hartack, 2. Beatrice Lillie
5/17 AF, Terry-Thomas, DK, BC Jack Lemmon
5/24 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Jayne Mansfield
5/31 AF, Paul Anka, DK, BC Liberace
6/7 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC 1. Sheilah Graham, 2. Helen Hayes
6/14 AF, SA, DK, BC Gina Lollobrigida
6/21 DK, Marty Ingels, AF, BC Frank Fontaine
6/28 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC Carroll Baker
7/5 DK, Rudy Vallee, AF, BC 1. Peter Gabel, 2. Sue Lyon
7/12 AF, Robert Q. Lewis, DK, BC E.G. Marshall
7/19 DK, Allen Ludden, AF, BC Jack Palance
7/26 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Peter Lawford
8/2 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Carol Channing
8/9 AF, Joseph L. Mankiewicz, DK, BC Olivia deHavilland
8/16 DK, Buddy Hackett, AF, BC Tony Randall
8/23 AF, Steve Lawrence, DK, BC Bob Cummings
8/30 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Paul Anka
9/6 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC Marty Allen & Steve Rossi
9/13 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC 1. Jerry Herman, 2. Henry Fonda
9/20 DK, BC, Carol Channing, AF Arthur Godfrey
9/27 DK, Frank Gifford, AF, BC Steve Lawrence & Eydie Gorme
10/4 AF, Buddy Hackett, DK, BC Steve Allen
10/11 DK, Sammy Davis Jr., AF, BC 1. Clete & Ken Boyer, 2. Phyllis Diller Hal Simms announcer
10/18 AF, Paul Anka, DK, BC Tony Bennett
10/25 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC James Garner
11/1 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
11/8 DK, Alan King, AF, BC Robert Goulet
11/15 AF, Groucho Marx, DK, BC Anne Bancroft
11/22 DK, Anthony Perkins, AF, BC Elizabeth Ashley
11/29 DK, BC, Carol Channing, AF Buddy Hackett
12/6 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Eddie Fisher
12/13 DK, Victor Borge, AF, BC Joan Crawford
12/20 AF, SA, DK, BC Jack E. Leonard
12/27 DK, Louis Jourdan, AF, BC Gene Kelly

1965Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/3 AF, Buddy Hackett, DK, Martin Gabel Jason Robards, Jr.
1/10 DK, Orson Bean, AF, BC Lee Remick
1/17 AF, Alan King, DK, BC 1. Minnesota Fats, 2. Ann Sothern
1/24 DK, William Shatner, Kitty Carlisle, BC Jack Lemmon
1/31 AF, Bobby Darin, DK, BC Jimmy Durante
2/7 DK, Victor Borge, AF, BC Floyd Patterson
2/14 AF, SA, DK, BC-NEW INTRO 1. Gloria Swanson, 2. Martin Gabel, Jayne Meadows, Richard Kollmar, & Phyllis Cerf
2/21 BC, Carol Channing, AF, Martin Gabel James Mason
2/28 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC Tommy Sands & Nancy Sinatra
3/7 DK, Buddy Hackett, AF, Martin Gabel Lucille Ball
3/14 AF, William Shatner, DK, BC Eli Wallach, Anne Jackson, & Alan Arkin
3/21 AF, Alan King, Carol Channing, BC Art Carney
3/28 DK, Congressman John Lindsay, AF, BC Robert Mitchum
4/4 AF, Martin Gabel, Sheila MacRae, BC 1. Johnny Olsen, 2. Maurice Chevalier
4/11 AF, Tony Randall, Marlo Thomas, BC George Jessel
4/18 AF, Abe Burrows, Anita Gilette, BC Marian Anderson
4/25 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Barbra Streisand
5/2 AF, Martin Gabel, DK, BC Jack Jones
5/9 DK, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Soupy Sales
5/16 AF, Paul Anka, DK, BC Liza Minnelli
5/23 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Robert Goulet
5/30 AF, Soupy Sales, DK, BC Anthony Newley & Joan Collins
6/6 DK, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Tallulah Bankhead
6/13 AF, SA, DK, BC Art Linkletter
6/20 DK, Jim Backus, AF, BC George Hamilton
6/27 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC Ethel Merman
7/4 DK, Steve Lawrence, AF, BC Trini Lopez
7/11 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC Jack Dempsey
7/18 AF, George Hamilton, DK, BC Milton Berle
7/25 DK, Michael Douglas, AF, BC 1. Carol Channing & Ginger Rogers, 2. Lucille Ball
8/1 AF, Tony Randall, DK, BC Jill St. John
8/8 AF, Martin Gabel, Carol Channing, BC Olivia De Havilland
8/15 AF, Tony Randall, Anita Gillette, BC Allan Sherman
8/22 AF, Alan King, DK, BC Steve Lawrence
8/29 DK, SA, AF, BC Betty Grable
9/5 AF, Robert Q. Lewis, DK, BC 1. Vonda Kay Van Dyke, 2. Betty White & Allen Ludden
9/12 DK, Steve Lawrence, AF, BC Edgar & Candice Bergen
9/19 AF, Joe Garagiola, DK, Martin Gabel Muhammad Ali
9/26 DK, Allen Ludden, AF, Martin Gabel Woody Allen
10/3 AF, Ralph Meeker, DK, Martin Gabel 1. Sean Connery, 2. Henry Fonda
10/10 DK, Jack Jones, AF, BC Gordon & Sheila MacRae
10/17 AF, Milton Berle, DK, BC Oscar Levant
10/24 DK, Buddy Hackett, AF, BC 1. Danny Kaye, 2. Yves St. Laurent, 3. Bette Davis
10/31 AF, SA, DK, BC Andy Griffith
11/7 DK, Tony Randall, AF, BC Joey Heatherton Dorothy Kilgallen was found dead at the age of 52, the morning after this program aired live.
11/14 AF, SA, Kitty Carlisle, BC Maureen O' Sullivan
11/21 AF, Tony Randall, Helen Gurley Brown, BC Ray Milland
11/28 AF, SA, Joanna Barnes, BC Hayley Mills
12/5 AF, Martin Gabel, Marianne Means, BC Edward G. Robinson
12/12 AF, Tony Randall, Betty White, BC Kate Smith
12/19 AF, Durwood Kirby, Phyllis Newman, BC Lauren Bacall
12/26 AF, Martin Gabel, Dina Merrill, BC 1. Alan Jay Lerner, 2. Buddy Hackett

1966Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/2 SA, Martin Gabel, AF, BC Geraldine Chaplin
1/9 Tony Randall, AF, Suzy Knickerbocker, BC 1. Hugh Hefner, 2. Polly Bergen
1/16 SA, AF, Jayne Meadows, BC Mickey Rooney
1/23 AF, Tony Randall, Joan Fontaine, BC 1. Maury Wills, 2. Dinah Shore
1/30 Tony Randall, AF, Joanna Barnes, BC 1. Sam Spiegal, 2. Hugh O' Brian
2/6 Tony Randall, Helen Gurley Brown, Martin Gabel, AF Carol Channing
2/13 Mark Goodson, Ginger Rogers, AF, BC Harry Belafonte
2/20 Martin Gabel, Suzy Knickerbocker, AF, BC Eddie Albert & Eva Gabor
2/27 AF, Digby Wolfe, Suzy Knickerbocker, BC 1. The Supremes, 2. Lana Turner
3/6 AF, Henry Morgan, Mary Lindsay, BC Paul Ford
3/13 AF, Tony Randall, Jeanne Parr, BC Robert Preston
3/20 Tony Randall, Dr. Joyce Brothers, AF, BC Carol Burnett
3/27 AF, SA, Barbara Douglas, BC 1. Walter Cronkite, 2. Art Carney
4/3 Tony Randall, AF, Pamela Mason, BC Woody Allen
4/10 AF, Larry Blyden, Jayne Meadows, BC Lee Remick
4/17 AF, Digby Wolfe, Peggy Cass, BC Arthur Godfrey
4/24 Phyllis Newman, Peter Ustinov, AF, BC Natalie Wood
5/1 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
5/8 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
5/15 AF, Tony Randall, Pamela Mason, BC Gwen Verdon
5/22 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
5/29 AF, Allen Ludden, Lee Remick, BC Soupy Sales
6/5 Phyllis Newman, Tony Randall, AF, BC 1. Jack Benny, 2. Vincent Edwards
6/12 Carol Channing, Mark Goodson, AF, BC 1. David Merrick, 2. Henry & Peter Fonda
6/19 AF, Larry Blyden, Suzy Knickerbocker, BC Jerry Lewis
6/26 Phyllis Newman, Tony Randall, AF, BC Carroll Baker
7/3 AF, Tony Randall, Suzy Knickerbocker, BC Joan Crawford
7/10 SA, Jayne Meadows, AF, BC James Mason
7/17 AF, Pierre Salinger, Phyllis Newman, BC Jayne Mansfield
7/24 AF, Joey Bishop, Helen Gurley Brown, BC Jean Pierre Aumont & Marisa Pavan
7/31 BC, Sue Oakland, Henry Morgan, AF Marty Allen & Steve Rossi
8/7 Phyllis Newman, Larry Blyden, AF, BC Shelley Winters
8/14 AF, Martin Gabel, Suzy Knickerbocker, BC Nancy Sinatra
8/21 SA, Jayne Meadows, AF, BC Walter Brennan
8/28 AF, Allen Ludden, Betty White, BC Pearl Bailey
9/4 Phyllis Newman, Buddy Hackett, AF, BC Joey Bishop
9/11 Steve Lawrence, Sue Oakland, AF, BC Warren Beatty Starting with this episode, all episodes taped in color at the Ed Sullivan Theatre.
9/18 Phyllis Newman, Woody Allen, AF, BC 1. Leontyne Price, 2. Peter Ustinov
9/25 SA, Jayne Meadows, AF, BC Cast of "Dinner at Eight"
10/2 AF, Martin Gabel, Sue Oakland, BC 1. Danny Kaye, 2. Abraham Ribikoff
10/9 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
10/16 AF, Larry Blyden, Suzy Knickerbocker, BC George Hamilton
10/23 Phyllis Newman, Dick Cavett, AF, BC 1. Suzy Knickerbocker, 2. Ed Sullivan
10/30 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
11/6 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
11/13 AF, Orson Bean, Sue Oakland, BC Michael Caine
11/20 AF, Larry Blyden Sheila MacRae, BC Virna Lisi
11/27 Phyllis Newman, Mark Goodson, AF, BC 1. Frank Sinatra, 2. Mia Farrow
12/4 AF, SA, Pia Lindstrom, BC Angela Lansbury
12/11 Phyllis Newman, Bob Crane, AF, BC 1.Tom Poston, Peggy Cass, Orson Bean, & Kitty Carlisle, 2.George Segal
12/18 AF, SA, Helen Gurley Brown, BC Steve McQueen
12/25 AF, Martin Gabel, Suzy Knickerbocker, BC Eva Marie Saint

1967Edit

Aired Panelists Mystery Guest(s) Notes
1/1 AF, Dick Cavett, Sue Oakland, BC Gina Lollobrigida
1/8 Phyllis Newman, Woody Allen, AF, BC Jane Fonda
1/15 AF, SA, Aliza Kashi, BC Abbe Lane
1/22 Sue Oakland, Tony Randall, AF, BC 1. Vince Lombardi, 2. Herb Alpert & the Tijuana Brass
1/29 AF, SA, Dina Merrill, BC Tom & Dick Smothers
2/5 Phyllis Newman, AF, Allen Ludden, BC 1. Tony Randall, 2. Chris Noel
2/12 Jayne Meadows, SA, AF, BC Yves Montand
2/19 AF, SA, Suzy Knickerbocker, BC Andy Griffith
2/26 AF, Woody Allen, Phyllis Newman, BC Marty Allen & Steve Rossi
3/5 AF, Tony Randall, Sue Oakland, BC 1. Jacqueline Susann, 2. Judy Garland
3/12 AF, Martin Gabel, Pamela Tiffin, BC 1. Jonathan Cerf & Peter Gabel, 2. Robert Morse
3/19 AF, Henry Morgan, Gypsy Rose Lee, BC Ursula Andress
3/26 SA, Jayne Meadows, AF, BC 1.Orson Bean, 2.Sid Caesar&Imogene Coca
4/2 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
4/9 Tony Randall, Sue Oakland, AF, BC Soupy Sales
4/16 Phyllis Newman, William Fine, AF, BC Candice Bergen
4/23 AF, Henry Morgan, Michele Lee, BC Groucho Marx
4/30 AF, George Grizzard, Phyllis Newman, Tony Randall Raquel Welch
5/7 AF, Martin Gabel, Michele Lee, Tony Randall Leslie Uggams
5/14 AF, Mark Goodson, Helen Gurley Brown, Tony Randall Allan Sherman
5/21 AF, Mel Ferrer, Suzy Knickerbocker, Tony Randall The Supremes
5/28 Phyllis Newman, Robert Q. Lewis, AF, BC Lawrence Welk
6/4 AF, Henry Morgan, Pia Lindstrom, BC 1. Jean Shrimpton, 2. Jack Jones
6/11 AF, Martin Gabel, Barbara Feldon, BC Melina Mercouri
6/18 Phyllis Newman, Joel Grey, AF, BC 1. F. Lee Bailey, 2. Betty Grable
6/25 SHOW PRE-EMPTED ON CBS
7/2 AF, Kevin McCarthy, Phyllis Newman, BC Betty Comden & Adolph Green Hal Simms announcer
7/9 Phyllis Newman, Henry Morgan, AF, BC Senator Everett M. Dirksen
7/16 Sue Oakland, Mark Goodson, AF, BC Allen Ludden, Gene Rayburn, Ed McMahon, & Bud Collyer
7/23 Phyllis Newman, Gene Rayburn, AF, BC Lauren Bacall
7/30 AF, Joel Grey, Phyllis Newman, BC Peggy Cass
8/6 AF, SA, Jayne Meadows, BC Jack E. Leonard
8/13 Phyllis Newman, Martin Gabel, AF, Tony Randall Woody Allen
8/20 AF, Henry Morgan, Joan Murray, BC Jill St. John
8/27 AF, Gene Rayburn, Phyllis Newman, BC Hugh O' Brian
9/3 Martin Gabel, AF, SA, BC John Daly

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.